good but not the best of WWII fiction
From Amazon
i didn't really relate to emma, dr.fitch, or iris. i had my moments of relating to frankie. i found some of the story to be very compelling, particularly the part of the book where frankie is traveling through europe. i thought the start of the story with iris going to/from boston was almost unnecessary except that it introduces emma on the bus. compared to the book thief and the guernsey literary and potato peel pie society, this was a weaker novel for me.
FELL SHORT
From Amazon
This book was recommended by a friend I trust. I thought it had its moments, but just fell short. I must say I listened to the audio version, and did not like the reader. Her male voice was bad, and Iris' accent kept changing. The story left me wanting. The female journalist in Europe at the beginning of WW II, and references to real journalists like Edward Murrow added to the story. Hitler's brutality, and the horrors of war were stark and real. I could not identify with Emma, nor her doctor husband. The end, where all was meant to be resolved, tested my patience. Two steps forward, and one back. Way too much angst over messages.
The real stretch for me was the unbelievable chance meeting in a London bomb shelter.
Interesting tale
From Amazon
I read this the same week I read "The Help" and "Wench" -- I liked both of those better than this one, though I'd still say this was interesting.
The Postmistress
From Amazon
I agree with the others who have given this book one star: the characters are flat and uninteresting, and many times their motivations are unclear. And I felt that the author didn't know where she was taking these characters. Consider the title of the book: "The Postmistress." It refers to Iris, but that character does not label herself a postmistress, but a postmaster. Perhaps the book's title was the publisher's doing, not the author's. Also, I didn't understand WHY it was important to Iris that she get a certificate from the out-of-town doctor saying she was still a virgin. And to begin a book telling your readers (at a fictional dinner party) that the premise of the book is to be about a postmistress who doesn't deliver letters, and have the dinner guests say "I'm hooked already!" when that premise is utterly boring, was a mistake, I thought. The character best thought out -- but who still remained two-dimensional -- was Frankie, gal correspondent. I hadn't heard of this author before, and perhaps her other book is better. This one was terrible, and I would NOT recommend it to any reader.
A Taste of Pre-WWII America
From Amazon
For me, this book was as much about war coverage of the period as it was about the characters that were living through it. When I think about WWII, I think about it from when the United States officially entered the war, although I know it started well before then. The whole premise of this story takes place before the US entered the war and I learned so much from this book about the American mind set of the time - we were safe, it was over there, it wouldn't happen to us. Sarah Blake does an incredible job of portraying the people of the small Cape Cod town of Franklin, Massachusetts. I loved hearing their discussions about what was going on "over there". Frankie Bard is over in the Blitz in London and later in France and Germany reporting back to those here in the US about the conditions in these places. She was the voice that brought this news back to the people and she tried to put emotion into the stories - so that people would actually feel what was happening.
Even though I certainly wasn't around during WWII, I could connect some of the points of the novel to what has been happening today - we are safe, it is over there, it couldn't happen to us. It's amazing how the author can really drag your perceptions of today into the novel and you can connect to it.
Three characters are the central focus of the story - Frankie Bard (the radio reporter), Iris James (the postmistress), and Emma Fitch (the doctor's wife). These three women are brought together by various events and consequences and really help each other survive. My favorite character by far was Emma Fitch. I think her hopes, fears, and desires were clear to the reader and consistent from start to finish - the most fleshed out character. I really had a hard time with the postmistress - who corrects people over and over that she is indeed a postmaster. I felt that she was a little all over the place. She starts out as this person who has always had all her ducks in a row and takes her job very seriously; when she withholds the letter, and her reasoning behind it, it felt very contrived and not within the character. For a book that is titled The Postmistress, I found Iris to not be the central focus or even the most important character.
To comment on the audiobook - I think that this was a great choice to listen to. When so much of the story is made up of Frankie's radio broadcasts, you really felt like you were listening to it the way it was meant to be. It added a touch of reality and I think it put me into the mindset of the time period easier. See my post later this week for some real radio broadcasts from the war.
Overall, I felt that this book brought home the feeling of ambivalence about the war in the US. The aspects of the book that were tied up the best were those that related to the war and what was happening. Some of the characters needed to be fleshed out a little more to be completely believable and that would have made the story much better.
3.5 stars.